First page    Previous    Next    Index

 

THE UNFC-2009 classification scheme as a possible tool for complex project characterisation and ranking

 

 

 The UNFC-2009 scheme

 

 

Generic, principles-based system (now applied for solid minerals, fossil energy, injection projects and geothermal)
Classifies a certain project in a numerical and language independent coding scheme.

E-axis: ‘Economic and social viability’ (degree of favourability of social and economic conditions in establishing commercial viability of project , e.g. market prices, relevant legal, regulatory, environmental and contractual conditions)
F-axis: ‘Field project status and feasibility’ (maturity of studies and commitments necessary to implement project)
G-axis: ‘ Geological knowledge’ (level of confidence in the geological knowledge and potential recoverability of the quantities)

 

 

The classification process

 

 1) defining a project, link between a geothermal energy source (equivalent to the terms ‘deposit’ or ‘accumulation’ used for solid minerals and fossil fuels) and the product (heat, electricity)

 

 

„Project” can be:

  • Expansion of an existing project
  • Greenfield development
  • Project in pre-drilling exploration phase
  • Regional evaluation of a geothermal play

 

2) estimating the quantities of energy that can be recovered and delivered as ‘products’ by the given project from the effective date of the evaluation forward (till the end of the project lifetime/limit), measured or evaluated at the reference point (a defined location in the production chain).

Estimation method / quantification  (e.g. production forecast, probabilistic resource estimation) is NOT PART of the classification exercise! – no standard method uniformly accepted.

 

 

3) classifying  the quantified geothermal energy resource based on the criteria defined by the E, F and G (sub)categories.

 

 

E-categories

 

Degree of favourability of social and economic conditions in establishing commercial viability of project (market prices, relevant legal, regulatory, environmental and contractual conditions, etc.).

 

 

E1: Extraction and sale economically viable
E2: Extraction and sale economically viable in the foreseebale future (5 yrs)
E3: Extraction and sale not expected to be economically viable in the foreseebale future, or too early stage for evaluation

 

 

F-categories

 

Project status and feasibility / technology (maturity of studies and commitments necessary to implement project).

 

 

F1: feasibility of extraction confirmed (ongoing production)
F2: preliminary studies exist, but feasibility of extraction subject to further evaluation (e.g. first well drilled)
F3: exploration phase, limited technical data (e.g. pre-drilling exploration)
F4: no project development identfied (in-situ quantities)

 

 

G-categories 

 

Geological knowledge (level of confidence in the geological knowledge and potential recoverability of the quantities).

 

 

G1: Quantities associated with a high level of confidenece (low estimate – P90)
G2: Quantities associated with a moderate level of confidenece (best estimate – P50)
G3: Quantities associated with a low level of confidenece (high estimate – P10)
G4: Potential based on indirect evidence

 

 

MC: repeated calculations with stohastically changing parameters (e.g. reservoir volume, temperature, etc.).
Confidental data can be incorporated into a probability distribution!

 

 

Example: Hódmezővásárhely geo-DH 

 

  • HU’s oldest geo-DH system 
  • operating since 1954, 
  • 8 production, 2 re-injection wells
  • Upper Miocene porous reservoir
  • partial reinjection 
  • 2725 flats, 130 public consumers
  • municipality owned company

 

    

 

Estimating the quantities: MC-based estimation of recoverable heat (volumetric method).

 

 

 

Classification of the Hódmezővásárhely project

 

2.88 PJ (E1, F1, G1)      2,81 PJ (E1, F1, G2)    8,04 PJ (E1, F1, G3)

 

 

Full granularity

 

 

 

IGA webpage on the UNFC Geothermal Specifications
https://www.geothermal-energy.org/resources_and_reserves/working_groups/unfc_2009_working_group.html

 

    First page    Previous    Next    Index